Freeport’s Garage Sale Chaos: A Symptom of Selective Enforcement and Broken Leadership

FREEPORT, IL – July 29, 2025

In a city that can’t seem to keep its rules straight, Freeport’s Garage Sale Ordinance (Chapter 840) has become just another example of a law ignored under the leadership of Mayor Jodi Miller and her administration.

Once a well-meaning effort to maintain order, fairness, and the integrity of residential neighborhoods, the ordinance—passed in 2006—has effectively been abandoned. And in a town as distressed as Freeport, the consequences go far beyond cluttered corners and misplaced signs.

What the Law Says — and How It’s Ignored

The ordinance allows residents to hold no more than three garage sales per year, limits operating days to Thursday through Saturday, and prohibits sales on Sundays. It also sets clear rules on signage, where property can be displayed, and outlines fines of $50 to $500 per day, per violation.

But today, those rules are widely ignored—and the city does nothing.

Garage sales now happen weekly, even daily, in some neighborhoods. Many are held on Sundays, with signs littering nearly every major intersection, light pole, and fence line across town. What should be a small exception to the rule has become the rule.

“Who Cares?” We All Should.

Let’s address the obvious: some reading this will shrug and ask, “Who cares? It’s just garage sales.”

To those people, we say — everyone should care. And here’s why:

Freeport has become a city almost entirely reliant on state and federal grant funding. We no longer function like a self-sufficient municipality. We have leaders who don’t lead — they chase handouts and ignore enforcement of existing law, all while claiming “fiscal responsibility.”

We were in the room when all eight alderpersons, the mayor, the city manager, and—for reasons still unexplained—Fehr Graham’s Darin Stykel debated whether to approve a basic request from the Freeport Police Department for more streetlights.

Instead of finding a way to say “yes” to public safety, Mayor Jodi Miller argued against putting up lights in high-crime, low-income areas, saying she couldn’t justify it unless her side of town got new lights too. That’s the kind of leadership we’re dealing with.

Missed Opportunity or Strategic Neglect?

This isn’t just about cluttered neighborhoods or fairness. It’s about the broader failure of leadership and a refusal to think creatively about solutions.

Imagine if Freeport took enforcement seriously—not punitively, but purposefully. Fines from rampant garage sale violations could be earmarked for specific needs:

  • Street lighting in underserved areas

  • Code enforcement clean-up crews

  • Subsidizing utility relief programs

  • Beautification of public parks

Instead, we get inconsistency and chaos. One resident is cited for grass an inch too tall, while their neighbor holds their seventh Sunday garage sale of the year with no consequence. Meanwhile, small businesses like our “countless” thrift stores—who play by the rules and pay taxes—are left wondering why the city lets others skirt regulation.

This is a leadership problem.

A City Divided by Neglect

In a city of 23,000, people are going to care about different things—and that’s okay. But when laws are enforced unfairly, and when residents doing their best to follow the rules are punished while others operate freely, resentment grows. And so does dysfunction.

Families struggling under the weight of inflation, multiple local tax increases, and economic stagnation care.
Residents shopping to stretch a dollar care.
Business owners who play by the rules care.
And every voter should care when the city’s laws mean nothing—unless it benefits those in power.

It’s Time for Leadership That Respects the Law — and the People

What Freeport needs isn’t just enforcement—it’s leadership with vision. Leaders who understand that ordinances aren’t just symbolic—they’re tools that, when used wisely, can uplift a city. Leaders who believe that enforcement should be equal, intentional, and focused on improving life for all residents.

It’s time to stop pretending these issues don’t matter. Because they do.

—Brought to you and paid for by Fighting4Freeport