November 18, 2026 | Freeport, IL
Presented by Elena Reyes
RED, RIGHT & BLUE | F4F NEWS
The Numbers Are In. Now Come the Questions.
Ten candidates. Two political parties. And 590 reported signature entries.
Freeport's 2027 municipal election is beginning to take shape, and the nomination papers offer an interesting first look at the political organizations preparing to compete for control of City Hall.
Fighting4Freeport's preliminary review of ten candidate petitions identified 383 signature entries submitted by six Democratic candidates, compared with 207 submitted by four Citizens Party candidates. That gives Democrats approximately 64.9% of the entries reviewed.
But the headline number doesn't tell the whole story. Across the four ward contests, the two organizations are separated by just five entries. And in the citywide Democratic contest for Alderman at Large, challenger Joshua T. Atkinson submitted 116 entries compared with 65 from incumbent Joy Sellers.
Those differences invite a closer look at the candidates themselves, particularly their public records and the decisions that have shaped Freeport's recent political debates.
Atkinson vs. Sellers: A Contest of Records, Not Just Signatures
The most substantial numerical difference between two candidates seeking the same office appears in the Democratic contest for Alderman at Large.
Joshua T. Atkinson submitted 116 signature entries, while incumbent Joy Sellers submitted just 65. That's a difference of 51 entries, meaning Atkinson's filing contained approximately 78.5% more entries than Sellers'.
But the more consequential comparison involves what each candidate brings to the race.
Sellers has served as Alderman at Large since 2023. Her time in office provides voters with an established record of council votes, public statements, and participation in decisions affecting city government. That record is receiving substantial attention amid ongoing debates over local taxation, municipal spending, and the future of the Greater Freeport Partnership. Critics have questioned whether Sellers has demonstrated sufficient independence from Mayor Jodi Miller's administration and the Citizen’s Party, particularly on controversial financial decisions.
Fighting4Freeport's September, October and the current November community survey reported a 36% approval rating for Sellers among participating respondents. Although the voluntary survey should not be interpreted as a scientific measure of citywide voter opinion, the result raises questions about how respondents view her performance.
The recent debates surrounding two local tax increases and the proposed elimination of municipal funding for the Greater Freeport Partnership provide specific matters for examining her record. Residents can reasonably ask how Sellers voted, what alternatives she considered, and how she explained her decisions.
City officials have defended greater scrutiny of the Partnership's finances and services as a matter of accountability. Supporters of the organization, meanwhile, have raised concerns about the consequences of eliminating funding for economic development. Understanding Sellers' individual position requires examining her actual votes and statements and how they align with the Miller agenda.
Atkinson enters the contest with a different record, one built outside elected municipal office.
Atkinson's Record: Fighting4Freeport and Beyond
As founder and chairman of Fighting4Freeport, Atkinson has become a visible participant in local debates over government transparency, public spending, election administration, and municipal accountability. The organization's reporting and investigations have examined City Council decisions, government contracts, public records, and financial issues affecting Freeport residents. Its work has also sought to make municipal proceedings and public information more accessible to people who might otherwise have limited opportunities to follow local government.
Atkinson's involvement has extended beyond publishing investigations and criticizing public officials. He has submitted proposals to the Freeport City Council, including a proposed ordinance intended to establish stricter local restrictions involving registered sex offenders, within the limits of Illinois law. His civic work has also included raising questions about municipal purchasing authority, public assets, financial oversight, and the use of taxpayer funds. Those activities demonstrate sustained engagement with city policy before holding elected municipal office.
There is an important difference between investigating government decisions and being responsible for making them. Atkinson's candidacy presents an opportunity to examine how the positions he has advocated as a citizen and publisher would translate into legislative priorities and council decisions.
For residents comparing the two candidates, the distinction is substantive: Sellers has an incumbent's voting record, while Atkinson has a record of civic oversight, public advocacy, and policy proposals. Both provide material for evaluating their respective approaches to public service.
Beyond Red and Blue: Atkinson's Cross-Party Approach
Atkinson's political history adds another dimension to the contest.
Although he is seeking the Democratic nomination for Alderman at Large, his political participation has crossed traditional party lines. His involvement in the 2026 Republican primary, which has become central to his current ballot-access dispute, is part of that history. Atkinson has also emphasized communicating with residents and public officials regardless of political affiliation, particularly when discussing government accountability, public safety, and municipal policy.
That approach is relevant in Freeport, where local politics involve Democrats, Republicans, and the Citizens Party. Municipal decisions concerning roads, taxes, policing, and public services affect residents regardless of how they vote.
The central question is how any candidate would turn those relationships into effective representation while remaining accountable to the people who elected them.
Six Democrats, 383 Signature Entries
Beyond the at-large contest, the Democratic filings include candidates in each of the four wards examined.
Atkinson led the Democratic field with 116 entries, followed by Sellers with only 65. Cecelia Stacy submitted 63 entries in Ward 5, Michal Urban submitted 52 in Ward 7, Rachel Simmons submitted 44 in Ward 3, and Amera Striegel submitted 43 in Ward 1.
Together, the six candidates accounted for 383 entries, averaging approximately 63.8 per candidate.
The two citywide at-large filings account for 181 of those entries, however, making it important not to confuse the overall Democratic total with the relative strength of the parties in individual wards.
The ward contests tell a much closer story.
Mayor Miller's Citizens Party: Four Candidates, 207 Entries
Four Citizens Party candidates submitted nomination petitions in the wards reviewed.
Jeffrey Slamp submitted 56 entries in Ward 1, Scott Davison submitted 48 in Ward 3, Thomas Endress submitted 50 in Ward 5, and Mary Lantz submitted 53 in Ward 7. Their combined total was 207 entries, averaging approximately 51.8 per candidate.
When compared directly with their Democratic counterparts, the differences are relatively small. Slamp submitted 13 more entries than Amera Striegel in Ward 1, while Davison submitted four more than Rachel Simmons in Ward 3. Democrat Cecelia Stacy submitted 13 more than Endress in Ward 5, and Lantz submitted just one more than Michal Urban in Ward 7.
Across those four contests, Citizens Party candidates submitted 207 entries compared with 202 for Democrats. That five-entry difference is one of the most important findings in the entire review. While Democrats account for nearly two-thirds of all entries examined, the ward-level totals are almost evenly divided.
It is a reminder that signature collection, party organization, and actual voter support are different measurements. None should be confused with the others.
Years of Municipal Leadership. What Comes Next?
Freeport's municipal political landscape has long included organizations operating under the Citizens and People's Party names. Mayor Jodi Miller's association with the Citizens Party makes the current slate of candidates part of a broader conversation about the city's governing direction. That conversation is taking place against a backdrop of difficult questions about local taxes, economic development, population trends, public services, and municipal spending.
The controversy surrounding the Greater Freeport Partnership illustrates how those questions intersect. City officials have raised concerns about financial oversight and accountability, while Partnership supporters have warned that eliminating municipal support could affect economic-development services. Residents deserve to understand the evidence behind both positions, the financial implications of the decisions, and the alternatives considered.
The same applies to the city's recent tax debates. When officials approve additional revenue measures, the public should be able to examine their stated purposes, the expected financial impact, and whether the resulting expenditures achieve their objectives. Candidates associated with the current administration can be asked to explain its decisions. Candidates proposing a different direction can be asked to provide detailed alternatives.
That is where the election conversation becomes more meaningful than a comparison of party labels.
Where Are Freeport's Republicans?
One of the more interesting features of the ten reviewed nomination packets is the absence of a Republican Party candidate.
The filings examined represent Democrats and Citizens Party candidates, leaving questions about the Republican organization's role in the municipal election.
Are Republican-aligned residents participating through the Citizens Party? Have prospective Republican candidates chosen not to run? Or are party organizers concentrating on other political contests?
The nomination packets cannot answer those questions, and they do not establish that no Republican candidate could enter through another legally available process.
Nevertheless, the absence of a Republican designation among the ten filings is a notable feature of the nomination picture and one worth following as the election develops.
Ballot Access: Another Question Before the Courts
The nomination review comes as Atkinson and fellow Democratic candidate Michal Urban pursue judicial review of decisions by the Freeport Municipal Officers Electoral Board.
Both candidates have challenged rulings concerning their eligibility for the February 2027 Democratic primary ballot. The disputes involve interpretations of Illinois election law, including their participation in the March 2026 Republican primary. Urban's case also involves findings concerning petition circulation and signature sufficiency.
The number of signatures submitted does not resolve those legal questions. The judicial-review proceedings will determine the issues properly before the court.
Whatever the outcome, the public has a legitimate interest in transparent election procedures, consistent application of the law, and clear explanations of decisions affecting ballot access.
The Final Word: Beyond the Petition Pages
Freeport's 2027 municipal election is still in its early stages, but the nomination papers have already provided several noteworthy comparisons.
Ten candidates submitted 590 reported signature entries. Democrats accounted for 383, while Citizens Party candidates submitted 207. Atkinson led the individual counts with 116 entries, compared with 65 from incumbent Sellers. Yet across the four ward contests, the parties were separated by only five entries.
Those figures are not polling results, and they cannot predict an election. They represent preliminary petition entries, not necessarily unique residents, verified signatures, or commitments to vote.
What makes the election worth examining is the record behind each candidate's name.
Sellers has council votes and decisions to explain. Atkinson has public advocacy, investigations, and policy proposals to substantiate. The ward candidates have their own records, priorities, and plans to present.
And every candidate faces questions that matter far more than a petition total: What have you accomplished? What would you change? How would you fund your priorities? And how will residents be able to measure the results?
The nomination papers tell us who has begun the process of seeking office. The candidates' answers to those questions will tell residents much more about what they are offering Freeport.
